Citation: Macleod G, Camarco W, “Making Medicine Easier to Take”. ONdrugDelivery Magazine, Issue 109 (July 2020), pp 6-9
Graeme Macleod and Wayne Camarco discuss the rational design of excipients to meet the needs of patient-centric formulations.
Regulators are increasingly insisting that formulators consider patient centricity in the dose form they are developing. This means, in addition to normal factors such as stability, efficacy, content uniformity, robustness and manufacturability, the organoleptics of the dose form must be considered from the start of any project.
“In an ideal world, the formulator would have a monograph excipient with all the benefits of a co-processed system. With this in mind, SPI Pharma set about development of a universal excipient.”
In solid dose form design, there has been a significant increase in the number of patient-centric dose forms coming onto the market to help meet these requirements. Orally disintegrating tablets (ODTs), chewable tablets, granules, resuspendable tablets or granules and orally dispersible powders are all examples of dose forms that help to improve patient adherence, particularly in patient groups – such as paediatrics and elderly patients – where this can be particularly challenging. Patient adherence can be enhanced with dosages that are easier and/or more pleasurable to take – e.g. orally disintegrating or chewable dosages with favourable taste and texture.
Despite the evolving requirements of patients and regulators alike, the introduction of excipients enabling formulators to meet these objectives has been minimal. Development of new excipients – or existing excipients with enhanced functionality – is time consuming and can be costly to excipient companies. Often the rewards do not meet the efforts expended. This conundrum requires excipient suppliers to think rationally about what the ideal “universal excipient” might look like to address these challenges.
UNIQUE COMBINATION OF MATERIAL SCIENCE AND APPLICATION KNOW-HOW
SPI Pharma was the first company to launch a co-processed excipient specifically aimed at rational design of ODTs. Our Pharmaburst® platform, for the first time, enabled the formulation of a directly compressible blend of API, excipient and lubricant that could meet the competing requirements of ODT development.
An ODT formulation needs to be sufficiently robust to withstand downstream processing, such as packaging, but at the same time disintegrate within 30 seconds in the mouth and impart a positive patient experience. SPI Pharma used its knowledge of key excipients, such as mannitol, and its co-processing expertise to design a system that met these needs. Since then, many other companies have launched similar products that were designed with ODT in mind.
Despite the success of these types of products, there remained some limitations in that the multi-component nature of co-processed systems meant they were not suitable across the board for a range of development projects. In an ideal world, the formulator would have a monograph excipient with all the benefits of a co-processed system. With this in mind, SPI Pharma began development of a universal excipient.
ENHANCED PERFORMANCE IN A FAMILIAR PACKAGE
Mannitol is widely used as an excipient in oral dose form development due to its low hygroscopicity and high stability or inertness. It does not undergo the Maillard reaction with amine APIs (unlike lactose) and has successfully been used to formulate some difficult actives in swallow tablets, such as levothyroxine. It has extremely pleasant organoleptics, with a mild sweetness and a minor cooling effect as it solubilises in saliva. This has made it the preferred excipient in ODT formulations and the base for most ODT platforms.
As more and more drugs are converted to patient-centric dose forms, it was clear that mannitol had many of the attributes required to fit the needs of a universal excipient, with all the requirements set out in Table 1. The main barrier to its ubiquitous use was its relatively low tabletability.
|Tabletability||medium to high; resultant tablets robust and low friability|
|Stability||inert, low hygroscopicity;|
|Organoleptics||sweet and cooling to the mouth; non gritty texture|
|Disintegration||fast inherent, with minimal need for disintegrant|
|Flowability||high; suitable for direct compression tableting processesFigure|
Table 1: What properties would a universal excipient possess?
For a formulator, the ability of an excipient to form a robust compact is critical, particularly in ODTs which generally have higher porosity or superior solubility to enable rapid disintegration. Formulators measure the tabletability of a given formulation by producing tablets over a range of compression forces and measuring the strength of the resultant tablet using standard equipment, such as a hardness tester, and converting the result into a tensile strength which considers the tablet thickness and diameter (Figure 1).
By taking the slope of the tensile strength versus compression force (Figure 2), the formulator can compare different formulations or excipients to understand the relative tabletability. The greater the tabletability, the more robust the resultant tablet will be and the lower the friability it will have. These are critical quality attributes (CQAs) that are key to rational drug design. If one could combine a high tabletability with the inherent stability, inertness and pleasant organoleptics, one would be close to having the universal excipient desired for rational dose form design.
Knowing this, SPI Pharma scientists set about trying to design this universal excipient. The result of more than 18 months of development work is the Mannogem® XL technology. In March 2020, SPI Pharma launched the Precious Gem Collection, which includes two new grades of Mannogem XL mannitol – “Ruby” and “Opal” – that we believe offers formulators an excipient that meets existing monograph needs and has universal applicability.
MANNOGEM XL RUBY
“Segregation of a powder blend containing API will lead to content uniformity issues, which is unacceptable because the patient would receive either higher or lower amounts of the drug, leading to possible side effects or subtherapeutic doses.”
Earlier, we explained the challenges in developing a chewable tablet or ODT. These challenges are amplified when formulators are required to develop a formula that requires taste masking. Taste masking is an absolute must for certain APIs that can be bitter or astringent in nature. These attributes can be particularly off-putting for children, who already need encouragement to take their medicines.
Fortunately, taste-masking approaches exist, such as SPI Pharma’s Actimask® technology, to help reduce the bad taste of a given API. In the majority of cases, the taste-masking approach requires application of a polymeric membrane to granules of the drug to help mask the bad taste. As a result of these taste-masking techniques, the resultant drug particles can be quite large (in pharmaceutical terms), easily greater than 300 microns.
Unfortunately, this causes another problem for the formulator. Blending a larger particle size API with a smaller particle excipient causes segregation of the active particles from the rest of the blend. A simple example of segregation is to think of granola. Anyone familiar with granola will know that the small particles – raisins and nuts – tend to settle at the bottom of the box, meaning the last few bowls are lacking in the larger particles. The same type of phenomenon occurs with direct compression blends with much more serious consequences.
Segregation of a powder blend containing APIs will lead to content uniformity issues, which is unacceptable because the patient would receive either higher or lower amounts of the drug, leading to possible side effects or subtherapeutic doses. Neither is acceptable. To overcome this issue, there are currently granular grades of mannitol on the market that have a larger particle size than the more common spray-dried grades.
By matching the taste-masked API particle with the larger particle size, it is possible to overcome the segregation described. However, until now, these grades of mannitol had even lower tabletability than the smaller particle size spray-dried grades. SPI Pharma’s Mannogem XL Ruby, for the first time, combines the large particle size of a granular mannitol with tabletability approaching that of spray-dried material.
Mannogem XL Ruby is a uniquely designed excipient that enables formulators to do things they were unable to contemplate previously. They can now formulate an ODT with all the benefits of mannitol that make it patient centric, but with the added benefit of incorporating taste-masked APIs that can be blended with confidence that drug segregation will not be an issue. Additionally, Ruby’s superior tabletability means there is less compaction force required, reducing the stress applied to pressure-sensitive formulation components, such as taste-masked APIs or multi-unit pellets systems (MUPS).
MANNOGEM XL OPAL
By extending this same functionality to a spray-dried product – Mannogem XL Opal – SPI Pharma can further extend the use of mannitol as a universal excipient, giving the most compressible grade of mannitol. As already described, the target for the formulation scientist is to have a rationally designed formulation that optimises the combination of high tabletability, low friability and rapid disintegration.
The superior tabletability of Opal enables the formulator to develop products that have high drug loading to a level that was not previously possible with mannitol. It also enables simplicity of formulation, negating the need to use other binders – such as microcrystalline cellulose and hydroxypropyl cellulose – which can undermine the organoleptics and accelerating development.
Additionally, smaller tablets are possible with Opal to enhance patient adherence by improving swallowability. An example of a simplified chewable tablet formulation is given in Table 2.
|Actimask® APAP 92M*||172.5|
|Mannogem XL Opal||989.1|
Table 2: Typical direct compression Mannogem XL Ruby APAP (acetaminophen) chewable tablet formulation. *Actimask APAP 92M is SPI Pharma’s taste-masked APAP, 172.5 mg equivalent to 160 mg of APAP
As formulations are transferred from development to manufacturing scale, the robustness of the formulation is key. The principles of quality by design require formulations to have a wide design space to minimise development time, particularly when it comes to technical transfers from development to production.
“Regulatory requirements and patient demands have pushed dose design earlier in the drug development process.”
Mannogem XL Opal has been uniquely designed to optimise the key attributes described above to give this robustness and wide design space. Such formulations will transfer to production quickly and enable high yields and fast production speeds to be achieved. Table 3 compares the performance of an Opal-based formulation with the same formulation that uses standard mannitol. As seen below, the Opal formulation is much more robust in terms of all the key CQAs.
Increasingly, the recent advances in regulatory expectations with respect to dose form patient centricity add to this challenge. With its Precious Gem Collection, SPI Pharma has taken the rational design approach and extended it to designing excipients that can significantly enhance patient-centric dose form functionality and formulation robustness.
Regulatory requirements and patient demands have pushed dose design earlier in the drug development process. Requirements for patient centricity in new drug development, and the need to match doses with consumer preferences in OTC development, have increased the importance of functional excipients that provide convenience and ease of administration. Mannitol is understood to be one of the best excipients to create easy-to-administer and aesthetically pleasing doses.
Simultaneously, drug delivery has become more sophisticated and dose development has become more complicated, requiring rational application of specifically functional excipients. In this respect, SPI Pharma has developed a collection of mannitol excipients that match targeted functionality, with the ability to make drugs easier to administer.
Excipients can no longer be generally applicable – they must provide specific functionality that can be applied to a rational design concept. Typical physical properties and applications of Mannogem XL Ruby and Opal grades are summarised in Table 4.
|Direct compression ODTs, swallow and chewable tablets||160||0.52||0.45|
|Direct compression ODTs and chewables with larger MUPS or taste-masked APIs where segregation is an issue||300||0.65||0.57|
Table 4: Typical physical properties and applications for Mannogem XL Ruby and Opal grades
Mannogem XL Ruby addresses the emerging need to create orally dispersible doses with large-particle, multicomponent ingredients. Mannogem XL Opal can help make tablets more robust with fewer ingredients. These new grades are a demonstration of excipients that are developed with drug development and patient needs in mind. Rationally designed excipients from SPI Pharma match the rational approach of the industry and meet the increasing demands of developing safe and efficacious medicines.